Rascal Flatts have no shortage of hit songs enjoyed by the masses, but what about their songs that never made it to radio? What’s their best deep cut?

Well, Rascal Flatts member and Grammy-winning producer Jay DeMarcus answered that question — in his opinion, of course — when he posted a video revealing his five favorite deep cuts from the famous trio’s album discography.

Surprisingly, we don’t always hear artists’ favorite songs on the radio. It takes a village to pick the “hit.” Sometimes, some of the best — and artists favorites — get left just for the fans who listen to the whole album. Those tracks that are never promoted as a single or sent to radio are know as deep cuts.

DeMarcus’ favorite: “It’s Not Just Me” — a ballad from the trio’s 2000 eponymous debut album.

Racal Flatts – “It’s Not Just Me” [Listen]

Curious what other songs he chose? Keep scrolling to take a look at what other tracks DeMarcus put as the Top 5 Rascal Flatts deep cuts. His answers might just surprise you.

Jay DeMarcus’ Top 5 Rascal Flatts Deep Cuts

5. “The Mechanic” (2014) – Rewind

4. “I Have Never Been to Memphis” (2014) – Rewind

3. “Holes” (2004) –  Feels Like Today 

2. “Dancing on My Grave” (2018) – Dancing on My Grave

1. “It’s Not Just Me” (2000) – Rascal Flatts

Nicole Taylor is part of Taste of Country Mornings with Wood and Nicole that can be heard every morning LIVE on TasteofCountry.com and on the Taste of Country app from 6-10 am Central. Based in Nashville, the two hosts talk with country artists and go deep into the latest in the world of country music every weekday.