In a world where Christmas albums often lean into bombast or overly polished production, John Van Deusen‘s In the Bleak Midwinter, is a tranquil revelation. This 14-track collection of Advent, Christmas, and Epiphany hymns, born out of the isolating days of the COVID-19 pandemic, radiates a lo-fi warmth that feels like an intimate conversation. Stripped of pretense and fussiness, this independent release from the Anacortes, Washington-based singer-songwriter offers a gentle, soul-soothing antidote to the season’s typical clamor. It’s a record that invites listeners to pause, reflect, and embrace the sacred simplicity of Advent, and it succeeds beautifully in its unassuming ambition.

Van Deusen, a veteran of the DIY scene, and former frontman of The Lonely Forest, crafted this album during his tenure as acting Director of Music, Worship, and Arts at Westminster Presbyterian Church in Anacortes. The context of its creation — livestreamed services during the pandemic’s lockdown — infuses the record with a palpable sense of reverence and vulnerability. As he notes when speaking of the album, “the hymns were chosen to bring calm to both himself and his congregation,” played with a capo high on the guitar neck to coax a softer vocal delivery. This intentional restraint carries over into the recording, done live at The Unknown studio with Nicholas Wilbur, where Van Deusen’s vocals and acoustic guitar form the heartbeat of the album. Overdubs of piano, bass, drums, and Andrew Joslyn’s exquisite string arrangements add depth without ever overwhelming the delicate core.

What sets In the Bleak Midwinter apart is its lack of artifice. There’s no grandstanding here, no attempt to reinvent the wheel with quirky arrangements or flashy production. Instead, Van Deusen leans into the timelessness of these public-domain hymns (save for “Little Drummer Boy”), delivering them with a raw, earnest charm that feels both reverent and deeply personal. Tracks like “Come Thou Long Expected Jesus” and “O Come, O Come, Emmanuel” shimmer with a hushed awe, their minimalist arrangements allowing the lyrics’ weight to resonate. The title track, with its Christina Rossetti-penned poetry, is a standout, Van Deusen’s tender vocals and Joslyn’s strings weaving a tapestry of quiet wonder. Even livelier tracks like “Go Tell It On the Mountain” maintain a grounded, unpolished tone that keeps the album cohesive.

This is music meant for candlelit moments, like a soft sigh of contentedness after a long day’s work. The lo-fi aesthetic — think warm tape hiss and organic textures — enhances its accessibility, making it feel like a homemade gift rather than a commercial product. Contributions, like Tenielle Neda’s vocal on “Hark the Herald Angels Sing” and Jess Alldredge’s additional violin, add subtle flourishes, but the spotlight remains on Van Deusen’s heartfelt delivery and the songs’ spiritual resonance.

For fans of artists like Sufjan Stevens or Manchester Orchestra, Van Deusen’s indie-folk sensibilities will feel like home, though In the Bleak Midwinter is less experimental than the former, and more subdued than the latter. Its strength lies in its simple sincerity, offering a low-key celebration of Advent that doesn’t demand attention, but gently earns it. As a reviewer, I find myself returning to this record for its ability to center my heart during the hectic holiday season. It’s not perfect — some might wish for a bit more dynamic variation — but its understated beauty is its greatest asset. For those seeking a Christmas album that prioritizes soul over spectacle, In the Bleak Midwinter is a treasure worth cherishing

– Review date: 7/4/25, written by Josh Balogh of Jesusfreakhideout.com